The eighteenth century was a
century mostly of religious calm, but of clouds of thick darkness overspreading
the whole face of civilization, turning the risen day into the semblance of dead
night--the darkness originating in England and extending to America, but
becoming denser on the continent of Europe, and densest in France; these
frightful clouds being occasioned by the thick and poisonous vapors arising from
a vast number of the earthy, sickly wild flickering tapers and torches of human
philosophy and human religion kindled by the wisdom of this world; but, rifting
these clouds, the powerful and glorious beams of the Sun of righteousness
irradiated some favored spots in Germany, and many more in the British Isles and
in the British North American Colonies, known, in the latter quarter of the
century, after a seven years' struggle for independence, as the United States of
America; while in wretched France the darkness deepened into the lurid blackness
of Tophet, and the deification of human reason, in the person of a harlot,
culminated in a Reign of Terror unparalleled in the annals of human history.
During the eighteenth
century, the low Arminianism and low morality of the latter part of the
seventeenth century produced, largely in Europe and somewhat in America, the
legitimate fruits of latitudinarianism, indifference, Arianism, Plagiarism,
deism, naturalism, philosophism, illuminism, perfectionism, universalism,
infidelity, aud materialism; and the seeds of these evils showed, especially in
Europe, their ungodly origin and nature in the production of an extraordinary
and terrible crop of worldliness, selfishness, avarice, venality, mild
speculation, lotteries, gambling, intemperance, profligacy, political
corruption, robberies, murders, and almost social chaos.('For a particular and
unimpeachable confirmation of the above remark. see W. E. H. Lecky's "England in
the Eighteenth Century, " vol. i.. latter part of the second chapter, and the
third and fourth chapters.)
The notorious, ignorant,
shallow, conceited, ambitious, avaricious and licentious infidel, Voltaire, who
was the echo of the drunken English debauchee, Bolingbroke, and the influential
companion of the German King, Frederick "the Great," was the leader of the
public opinion of the eighteenth century. The disguised unbelief of the latter
part of the seventeenth century became the blatant infidelity of the eighteenth
century, denying the possibility and credibility of miracles and of a, Divine
revelation and of everything supernatural, declaring all religion either merely
natural or a nullity, find idolizing human reason and human morality or human
benevolence. The infidelity of eighteenth century appeared first as deism in
Protestant England and America, and afterwards as historical and ethical
rationalism in Protestant Germany, and as materialistic atheism in irreligious,
ecclesiastically and politically oppressed Roman Catholic France. The lurid and
ghastly horrors of the French Revolution should, as a lofty and terrific beacon
light, forever warn the world of the legitimate effects of the substitution of
human reason and "free-thinking" for the religion of the Bible, or for even for
a nominal adherence to the religion of the Bible. Immanuel Kant, of Germany
(1724-1804), the greatest of all modern mental philosophers, is well called by
Mr. John Cairns "the highest summit of rationalism." He idealized all the
positive truths of Christianity, and reduced it to a perfect but were system of
morality; and, while inconsistently admitting, beyond all other philosophers,
the doctrine of human depravity taught in the third chapter of Genesis, and of
the necessity of regeneration taught in the -third chapter of John, he, like all
his rationalizing brethren, made this regeneration, not the work of God's
Spirit, but the work of man's own will and free agency. He, like them, fondly
quoted one-half of the Apostle's language-" Work out your own salvation with
fear and trembling," but carefully omitted the concluding remark of the Apostle,
"For it is God who worketh in you both to will and to do of His good pleasure"
(Philip. ii. 12, 13). Like many of his rationalizing followers in the nineteenth
century, Kant "sees the progress of the kingdom of God in a kind of euthanasia
(easy death) and ultimate disappearance of historical Christianity!" (The ablest
books written in the eighteenth century against infidelity were Joseph Butler's
"Analogy of Religion, Natural and Revealed, to the Constitution and Course of
Nature," acknowledged by even John Stuart Mill to prove conclusively that the
Christian religion is open to no objections, either moral intellectual which do
not apply at least equally to the common theory of Deism; Nathaniel Lardner's
"Credibility of the Gospel History;" William Pale's "Natural Theology" and "Horae
Paulinae:" and Richard Watson's "Apology for Christianity" addressed to Edward
Gibbon and "Apology for the Bible" addressed to Thomas Paine (the term "Apology"
in these last two titles having its old meaning of Defense or Vindication).
The characteristics of the
eighteenth century were a dead formalism, not only in the Catholic, but also,
more or less, in all-the Protestant communions; the general discontinuance of
doctrinal, experimental, spiritual and extemporaneous preaching, and the
substitution, in its place, of cold, lifeless, written moral essays ( ''Never,"
says the Schaff-Herzog Encyclopaedia of Religious Knowledge--"Never were such
elegant moral sermons preached, and never had immorality reached so high a
point." "Moral essays," says Mr. Lecky, "were utterly incapable of transforming
the character and arresting and reclaiming the thoroughly depraved.") read in
the pulpit; the unconverted state. not only of most of the private members, but;
also of most of the ministers of nearly all denominations; the immersion of the
"clergy" in the gayeties [gaieties] and vanities of the world; the intolerable
intrigues and corruptions of the Jesuits, and their almost total extermination
from China, their overthrow in Paraguay, their expulsion from Portugal, France,
Spain, Naples, Malta and Parma, and the suppression of their order by Pope
Clement XIV. in 1773, he dying the next year by poison supposed to have been
administered by them; the occasional persecution of Protestants in Catholic
countries, and of dissenters in England and America, but the general prevalence
of religious toleration occasioned by religious indifference, providence thus
overruling evil for good, and establishing the original New Testament and
Baptist principle of soul-liberty or freedom of conscience, more extensively
than ever before in the world, and especially in the United States; the
Particular or Predestinarian Baptist ministers, both in England and America, in
this undoctrinal, indifferent, Arminian (The Methodist writer, Richard Watson,
the prince of Arminians, in his "Observations on Southey's Life of Wesley,"
remarks of this age: "There was something of ultra-Calvinism, and much of
frigid, unevangelical Arminianism.'',) Pelagian, corrupt, antichristian age,
laying the axe at the root of the tree of human pride and corruption, and
insisting upon the great radical reformatory Bible principles of total
depravity, personal election, particular redemption, effectual calling and final
perseverance--these Divine and eternal truths being stigmatized as
"Hyper-Calvinism " and "Antinomianism" by those who erred because not knowing
the Scriptures nor the power of God; the publication, in 1784, of "The Gospel
Worthy of all Acceptation," by Andrew Fuller, of England, who may almost be
considered the founder of the New School or so-called "Missionary" Baptists; and
who in this work modernized and moderated Calvinism by maintaining a general
atonement with special application, and consequently urging that the gospel
should be offered freely and indiscriminately to all men, whether they had ears
to hear or hearts to receive it or not,--this work involving him in a bitter
controversy of nearly twenty years with his brethren, and resulting in the
conversion of most of them to his views; many of the General or Arminian
Baptists degenerating into Arianism and infidelity, and some of them being
converted to the scriptural views of the Strict Particular Baptists; the success
of pietism, under Spener and Francke, in Germany, containing, as it did, much
legalism, but also some highly important evangelical truths, such as the
indispensable necessity of a spiritual birth, and of the religion of the heart
and life; the origin, in Germany, under Zinzendorf, and the most extensive
spread over the world, by schools and zealous, self-denying missions, costing
but little money (the first Protestant missions not undertaken in connection
with the planting of colonies), of a new Moravianism, characterized at first by
many gross excesses, but emphasizing the importance of a personal, vital, inward
experience of religion, making the gospel, the grace and love and perfection of
Christ, so prominent, tithe almost entire exclusion of the law, as to be accused
of Antinomianism; the great religious awakening, in the British North American
Colonies, under the fervent preaching, first, in 1734, of the intensely
predestinarian Congregationalist, Jonathan Edwards, and then, in 1740 and
afterwards, of the strongly Calvinistic Methodist, George Whitefield--the
extraordinary spiritual blessings of their ministry permeating all the religious
denominations, particularly the Congregationalists, the Presbyterians and the
Baptists, in all the colonies, Edwards, the greatest theologian of America,
being especially careful to promote and restore Bible purity of doctrine, and
exercising a, great influence on Whitefield in this regard; the rise and rapid
multiplication, in the British Isles and the United States, of Methodist
Societies, under the preaching of Whitefield and the Wesleys, Coke and Asbury
and others, Whitefield being Calvinistic and the Wesleys Arminian--all the true
success of this extensive movement being due to the Holy Spirit's blessing the
highly important, but generally forgotten, spiritual and evangelical truths
fervently proclaimed by the first Methodist preachers, "the utter depravity of
human nature, the lost condition of every man who is born into the world, the
vicarious atonement of Christ, the necessity to salvation of a new birth, of
living, sanctifying, justifying faith, of the constant and sustaining action of
the Divine Spirit upon the believer's soul"--and the false success of the
movement being due to the extreme Arminianism of the Wesleys, to an unequalled
system of religious terrorism and the consequent ingathering of a large
unconverted membership, to the attachment of the Wesleys to the Anglican
Establishment, the retaining of infant baptism, and to an at first imperial and
then oligarchical unscriptural organization.
The eighteenth was also the
century of the rise of Swedenborgianism, or the so-called "New Jerusalem
Church," established by Emanuel Swedenborg, a Swede (1688-1772), who professed
to have been divinely inspired from 1743, and to have lived the remainder of his
life in inter-course with the world of spirits, and to have seen the last
General Judgment of the world in 1757,--the second coming of Christ and the
setting up of the New Dispensation, the New Jerusalem Church, then taking place.
He professed to preach a new gospel, which was not a gospel; he rejected or
rationalized away (he called it spiritualizing) nearly all the fundamental
principles of Christianity, as commonly understood, denying the tripersonality
of God and the personality of the Devil, the vicariousness or reality of the
atonement, the resurrection of the body, the future general judgment, and the
destruction of the world; he claimed to understand the internal sense of the
Scriptures better than the Apostles did; he taught, like Mohammed, that Heaven
is material, and that marriage will be continued there, notwithstanding the
declaration of Christ to the contrary (Matthew xxii. 30). He also taught that
all religions, even those of the heathens, contain the essence of saving truth;
that man's will is free; that God loves all alike, and gives Himself equally to
all, but all do not receive Him; and the system of salvation inculcated by
Swedenborg went beyond the last verge of Arminianism, and plunged into the
depths of Pelagian darkness. It is mournful that this theosophic mysticism is
gaining much ground, in various quarters, in the nineteenth century.
During the eighteenth century
also arose the Shakers, a kind of off-shoot from the Quakers, originating in
England, but emigrating and now confined to the Northern United States. These
people worship Ann Lee (1736-1784), a very poor, uneducated Englishwoman, who
married when very young, and lost four children in their infancy, and who became
opposed to marriage, and left her husband, the latter then marrying another
woman. Ann professed to be the manifestation or the second appearing of Christ
in His glory; and she taught her followers celibacy (called by Paul a "doctrine
of devils," Tim. iv. 1-3) and community of goods. The Shakers are mostly
farmers, living together and having; all things in common, and worshipping their
"Eternal Mother" with measured dance and song. They are spiritualists, and
reject vicarious atonement, the resurrection of the body, a future general
judgment, and predestination and election. Like the Swedenborgians, they are not
only Arminians, but thorough-going Pelagians, maintaining that the will is free;
that Heaven is opened by man's good deeds, and hell by his evil deeds; and that
man will have a chance of saving himself, not only before, but after death. They
are said now (1886) to number about five thousand members, in seventeen
communities, and to be worth about ten million dollars, The sect called
Glassites, in Scotland (from John Glass, 1695-1773), and Sandemanians, in
England and America (from Glass's son-in-law Robert Sandeman, 1718-1771), sprang
from the Presbyterians in the eighteenth century, advocating the independency,
and voluntary support of churches, and that "faith is a bare belief of the bare
truth;" though both Glass and Sandeman, with at least their immediate adherents,
regarded faith as the fruit of Divine grace and the work of the Holy Spirit.
They at first observed feet-washing, but have now discontinued it. Some of their
peculiarities are weekly love-feasts, the kiss of charity, abstinence from blood
and things strangled, plurality of Elders in every church, prohibition of games
of chance and of college training, and an adherence to the most literal
interpretation of Scripture. They have decreased in the nineteenth century, and
now number less than 2,000 members.
Modern Protestant Missions
originated in the eighteenth century. The English "Society for Propagating the
Gospel in Foreign Parts," established in 1701, devoted itself to the diligent
dissemination of High-Church Episcopalianism. The Danish Government, under the
influence of the German Pietist, A. H. Francke, sent out a few missionaries to
India in 1705, to Lapland in 1716, and to Greenland In 1721. The Moravian
Zinzendorf sent out from 1732 to 1750 "more missionaries than the combined
Protestant Church in two hundred years--illiterate laymen, who were enjoined to
practice rigid economy, labor with their own hands, use only spiritual means,
and aim at the conversion of individuals." Thomas Coke, John Wesley's
"right-hand," " the embodiment of Methodist Missionism," established in 1786 a
mission among the Negroes in the West Indies. "The independent Protestant
Missionary Societies formed in this century may be regarded as a substitute for
the Orders of the Roman Church," says the able and accurate Schaff-Herzog
Catholic Encyclopaedia of Religious Knowledge. The "Baptist Society for
Propagating the Gospel amongst the Heathen" was formed at Kettering, England,
October 2d, 1792, under the influence of Andrew Fuller, William Carey, and
others, and operated in India. The "London Missionary Society" was formed in
1795, soon passed under the control of the Independents, and began work in the
South Sea Islands and South Africa. The "Society for Missions to Africa, and the
East" was formed in 1799 by Episcopalians.
The modern system of Sunday
Schools originated in the eighteenth century. The patriarchs, by Divine
direction, taught religious truths to their own children. The prophets gave
religious instruction to all, both old and young, who were prepared to receive
it. Ezra and his assistants "read to all who could hear with understanding in
the book of the law of God distinctly, and gave the sense, and caused them to
understand the reading" (Neh. viii.). After the Babylonian captivity, the Jews
established synagogues, and religious schools in connection with them, in almost
every town in Palestine. In the second century of the Christian era,
Catechetical schools were established in connection with many churches to give
religious instruction to the young and ignorant; and these schools were
especially flourishing in the fourth and fifth centuries. In the Middle Ages,
the Roman Catholic ''Church" being engrossed with the wholesale "conversion" of
nations by the sword, it is said that catechetical instruction was given by the
so-called "heretics," the Cathari, Waldenses, Wycliffites, Bohemian Brethren,
etc. In the sixteenth century the Reformers, to some extent, instituted
catechetical instruction on Sundays. But Robert Raikes, of Gloucester, England,
is generally admitted to have been the founder of modern Sunday Schools. In 1781
he hired teachers to instruct some poor children in Gloucester in reading and in
the catechism on Sunday. His example was extensively imitated in the British
Isles and the United States; and, by the end of the eighteenth century, the
instruction had almost universally become gratuitous, and was said to be far
superior in quality to what it was before, because now springing from pure
benevolence. It is claimed by the Methodists that John Wesley, first in 1784,
suggested that the instruction should be gratuitous, and also expressed the hope
that Sunday Schools would become "nurseries for Christians" (See the Article on
Sunday Schools in McClintock and Strong's Encyclopedia of Biblical, Theological
and Ecclesiastical Literature, vol. x., p. 21). The writer of the Article just
mentioned declares that, "within the last fifty years Sunday Schools have come
to be regarded as an essential branch of church action, not merely in England
and America, but throughout the Protestant world whether in home or mission
fields;" and he intimates, at the conclusion of his Article, that, in the Sunday
School, he sees "the problem of the conversion of the world in process of
solution." It thus appears that, for nearly 1,800 years of the Christian era,
the church was destitute of an " essential" requisite in its work, and the
problem of the conversion of the world had not begun to be solved!
The extermination of the
Jesuits from China was due to the success of their jealous brethren, the
Dominicans, in finally prevailing on the pope to compel the Jesuits to abandon,
in that country, their heathen customs and accommodations this step provoking
the Chinese to destroy hundreds of thousands of them. The rationalistic Lutheran
theologians (Johann Lorenz von Mosheim, the eloquent and learned Lutheran
preacher and church historian, was born about 1694, and died 1755. "His noble
character," says Hagenbach. "is just as lovely as his learning was thorough and
comprehensive.",) Ernesti, Michaelis and Semler, declared that the Bible was to
be explained and interpreted just like any other book; vainly substituted their
own ideas for the thoughts of the inspired writers; set aside the great
doctrinal truths of revelation as rhetorical types and bold metaphors, the
Asiatic language of' emotion and imagination, and not the modern European
language of strict scientific accuracy; distilled away the positive facts of
Christianity in pretending to get at its essence; and founded schools of thought
which have filled almost all the professors' chairs and pulpits in Protestant
Germany during the nineteenth century.
The Anglican Establishment
showed but few signs of spiritual life during the eighteenth century; it was
nearly buried under the rubbish of formalism, skepticism and corruption. "In
America it was a sickly exotic, striking no deep roots into the soil, and it
almost withered away when scorched by the fervent heat of the Revolutionary
epoch. Not only was it then regarded as disloyal to the Colonies, but it had
long been looked upon as not promotive of piety." In the latter part of the
eighteenth century, a very limited but genuine revival of spiritual life was
manifested in the Anglican communion in the true conversions and godly lives and
labors of William Romaine (1714-1793), whose sermon on "The Lord our
Righteousness" excluded him forever afterwards from the pulpit of Oxford
University, and who wrote three admirable works called "The Life of Faith," "The
Walk of Faith," and "The Triumph of Faith;" of A. M. Toplady (1740-1778), who
edited "The Gospel Magazine," combated the Arminianism of John Wesley,
maintained the doctrinal Calvinism of the "Church of England," and published a
volume of Psalms and Hymns, among which were his own excellent compositions,
"Rock of Ages, cleft for me; Let me hide myself in Thee," "When languor and
disease invade this trembling house of clay" "Prepare gracious God" and "Your
harps, ye trembling saints, down from the willows take;" of John Newton
(1725-1807), who was converted from infidelity and profligacy, and became curate
of Olney in Buckinghamshire, was an able minister of the New Testament, and
wrote charming spiritual letters, and published the "Olney Hymns," many of which
were written by himself, among these being, "Amazing grace, how sweet the
sound," " In evil long I took delight," "Sweet was the time when first I felt,"
"Approach, my soul, the mercy-seat," "Come, my soul, thy suit prepare," "'Tis a
point I long to know," "Mercy, O thou son of David," "Savior, visit Thy
plantation "How tedious and tasteless the hours," " How sweet the name of Jesus
sounds," and "Glorious things of thee are spoken;" of William Cowper
(1731-1800), the best of English letter-writers. and the gentlest and purest of
English poets, who was for several years of his life, at intervals, melancholic
and insane but who had a profound religious experience, and who wrote
sixty-eight of Newton's 280 Olney Hymns, including, "I thirst, but not as once I
did," "God moves in a mysterious way," "The Spirit breathes upon the word,"
"'Tis my happiness below," "Sometimes a light surprises," "Hark, my soul, it is
the Lord," "When darkness long has veiled my mind," "O for a closer walk with
God," "The Lord will happiness Divine," " God of my life, to Thee I call," "Far
from the world, O Lord, I flee," "There is a fountain filled with blood" and
"Grace, triumphant in the throne;" of Joseph Milner (1744-1791) and Isaac Milner
(1751-1820), who were brothers, and authors of an evangelical church history; of
the eccentric, able and pious brothers, Richard Hill (1733-1808) and Rowland
Hill (1744-1833); and of Thomas Scott (1747-1821), who is considered the
expiring defender of Calvinism in the " Church of England," who wrote an account
of his own experience in the "Force of Truth," and excellent Notes on Bunyan's
Pilgrim's Progress, and whose " Family Bible, with Notes," has probably been
read more widely than any other. The marginal references to parallel passages in
Scott's Bible are exceedingly copious and valuable. My father, Elder C. B.
Hassell, owned, consulted and esteemed this work: and while under deep exercise
of soul I was reading Scott's Practical Observations on verses seventeen to
thirty in the nineteenth chapter of the Gospel of John, I was blessed with the
first believing, melting and adoring view of the Lord Jesus Christ suffering on
the cross and atoning for my sins. Though twenty-three years ago, I being then
twenty-one years of age. I remember the time and place as distinctly as if the
event had occurred but yesterday. It was Monday afternoon, August 17th, 1863
while I was alone in my own bedroom in my father's house. The precious were
blessed words thus blessed of God to me were the following: "We cannot wholly
pass over this narrative of our Redeemer's crucifixion without again reflecting
for a moment on the complicated cruelties and indignities to which He was
exposed. and not for any fault of His own, nay; directly contrary to His
deservings. But He was wounded and scourged, that we might be healed: He was
arrayed with scorn in the purple robe that He might procure for us sinners the
robe of righteousness and salvation. He was crowned with thorns, that we might
be crowned with honor and immortality; He stood speechless, that we might have
an all-prevailing plea: He Endured torture, that we might have a strong
consolation; He thirsted. that we might drink of the waters of life: He bore the
wrath of the Father that we might enjoy His favor; He was numbered with
transgressors, that we might be made equal to angels; He died, that we might
live forever! Let us then often retire to survey this scene, and to admire His
immeasurable love; that we may learn to mourn for sin and hate it, and rejoice
in our obligations to the Redeemer; and we may be constrained by love to live no
longer to ourselves. but to Him who died for us and rose again." I felt that the
language of Zechariah xii. 10 was fuIfilled in me: and I wished to weep forever
shed an ocean of tears for my wretched sins that had slain the Lord of life and
glory. From the subsequent and permanent effects of this exercise, I was led to
believe that it was the gracious work of the Spirit of God.
Mr. Scott was, in early life,
a poor farm-laborer, and had scarcely any educational advantages; yet his
religious writings were sold (mostly in America) even during his life to the
value of more than a million dollars, although they were sold at about the cost
of publication. He was a moderate Pedobaptist and a moderate Calvinist, but a
spiritual-minded, reverential, godly, humble and benevolent man. Multitudes of
the poor deeply mourned his death, feeling that they had lost a devoted friend.
He tenderly relates, in his autobiography, the evidences of the genuine
conviction and conversion of his little daughter, who died at the age of four
years and a half. In the preface to his sermon on Election and Final
Perseverance, Mr. Scott remarks: "Perhaps speculating Antinomians abound most
among professed Calvinists; but Antinomians, whose sentiments influence their
practice, are innumerable among Arminians. Does the reader doubt this? Let him
ask any of those multitudes who trample on God's commandments, what they think
of predestination and election; and he will speedily be convinced that it is
undeniably true; for all these, in various ways, take occasion from the mercy of
God to encourage themselves in impenitent wickedness." At the close of this
sermon occur the following observations: "And now in applying the subject I
would observe that, while numbers argue with the greatest vehemence against the
points in question. and groundlessly charge them with implying the most
dishonorable thoughts of God, and tending to the most pernicious consequences
others are ready to say in extravagant zeal, to any one of greater moderation,
'If you really believe these doctrines. why do you preach them so sparingly
cautiously and practically? I would desire such a man carefully to study even
St. Paul's Epistles, and to answer the objection himself. Perhaps he may find
that there is not a less proportion on such subjects in our sermons and
publications than in his writings; and that he as carefully guards them from
abuse, and connects them as much with holy practice, as we can do. We generally
meet with a few verses in an Epistle upon the doctrines in question; a much
larger proportion upon the person. love and sufferings of Christ. and on faith
in Him: and whole chapters upon a holy life and conversation; and, if we do not,
in like manner, proportion, guard and connect them, hypocrites will abuse them,
infidels will despise them, and the weak will be stumbled. Indeed, they are not
at all proper subjects to dwell on when we preach to (unconverted) sinners. to
prejudiced hearers, or newly-awakened persons: and are seldom if ever found in
Scripture explicitly thus addressed: yet a great part of our more public
ministry is exercised among such persons. Let it not then be thought carnal
policy to adapt our discourses to the occasions and wants of the hearers, while
nothing inconsistent with truth is spoken nothing profitable kept back. Our Lord
Himself says, I have yet many things to say unto you, but ye cannot bear them
now: and Paul writes to some who were prone to be wise in their own conceits, I
could not speak unto you as unto spiritual, but as unto carnal. I have fed you
with milk, and not with meat. for hitherto ye were not able to bear it; neither
yet are ye now able; and he gives a reason for his conduct, which proves that
many in most congregations are not able, namely, the prevalence of strife and
contention among them." And, in the last year of his life, he remarked, in a
letter to a friend: "Indeed, eager, vehement, speculating Arminianism is most
nearly allied to Plagiarism, and the transition is almost imperceptible." Says
Mr. Toplady: "I consider that Arminianism is the original of all the pernicious
doctrines that are propagated in the world, and Destructionism will close the
whole of them."
In the last year of his life
Mr. John Wesley (1703-1791) published a letter in which he wrote: "I live and
die a member of the Church of England, and no one who regards my judgment or
advice will ever separate from it." He designed only to found a "Society" in the
Anglican communion; and he declared he wished that the very name of "Methodists"
"might never be mentioned more, but be buried in eternal oblivion." He was so
staunch an Anglican that he not only wrote a pamphlet against the American
cause, but also offered to raise troops for the British government against the
Colonies; and all his preachers in America, except Francis Asbury, on the
breaking out of the Revolutionary War, fled to England. In the matter of church
polity, he conceded that the three orders of Deacons, Priests and Bishops early
appeared in the church, but he denied that these three orders are enjoined in
Scripture. He considered himself, though ordained only as a "priest" in the
"Church of England," a. scriptural "Bishop;" and he ordained Thomas Coke as a
superintendent of American Methodists, for the purpose, merely, of recommending
his delegate to his followers in America--though "Coke, in his ambition, wished
and intended the ceremony to be considered as an ordination to a bishopric." As
for an uninterrupted succession of Bishops from the Apostles, Wesley declared
that it was a "fable which no man ever did or could prove." Wesley governed his
Societies with absolute power; and in 1784, towards the close of his life, he,
by his famous "Deed of Declaration," vested similar power in an Annual
Conference of a hundred preachers and their successors. He received into his
Societies all persons who expressed "a desire to flee from the wrath to come and
be saved from their sins." He taught that even the heathens, who do their duty
according to their knowledge, are capable of eternal life. and have sometimes
enjoyed communion with the spiritual world, instancing Socrates and Marcus
Antoninus as examples.
He prepared, especially for
his American Societies, his Articles of Religion, at first twenty-four in
number, increased to twenty-five by the adoption, in 1804, of the twenty-third
Article ("Of the Rulers of the United States of America"), and in 1832 placed
beyond the power of the "Church" to "revoke, alter or change" them. These
Articles were an abridgment of the "Thirty-nine Articles of the Church of
England," Wesley omitting the Calvinism of the Thirty-nine Articles, and not
inserting his own Arminianism or other peculiar doctrines his design being to
provide a broad and liberal platform for all professed Christians to stand upon.
He believed in the inspiration both of the Scriptures and of himself, and
therefore made the doctrines of his Sermons and his Notes on the New Testament
(mostly adapted from Bengel's Gnomon) the legal basis of his Societies. He
generally preached briefly and extemporaneously, often selecting a text after he
entered the pulpit; but sometimes, on special occasions, he spoke from
manuscript. He is said to have traveled 280,000 miles in his preaching tours,
and preached, in the fifty years of his itinerant ministry, 42,000 sermons; also
to have written, translated or edited 200 religious works, and for the latter to
have received a hundred thousand dollars, which, however, with almost all his
other receipts, he gave away in charities, so that he died poor. He left, in his
Societies at his death, 541 itinerant preachers, and 135,000 members. "In
general," says the Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Wesleyan theology is to be
described as a system of evangelical Arminianism. In particular, Wesleyan
ministers insist on the doctrines of original sin, general redemption,
repentance, justification by faith, the witness of the Spirit, and Christian
perfection" by "the witness of the Spirit" meaning, they say, a sense of sins
forgiven, but not necessarily final salvation; and, by "Christian perfection,"
meaning, not sinlessness, but the perfection of love, which they believe to be
attainable in the present life. As Wesley "grew older, cooler and wiser, he
modified and softened down his doctrine of Perfection, so as almost to explain
it away."
The doctrinal essence of
Methodism is thus well stated in the American Cyclopaedia: "Methodism holds that
the salvation of each human being depends solely on his own free action in
respect to the enlightening, renewing and sanctifying inworkings of the Holy
Spirit (which this system holds to be universal). If, in respect to these
inworkings, he holds himself receptively, he will be saved both here and
hereafter; but if he closes his heart against these influences of the Spirit, he
will continue in death both here and in eternity." Wesley taught that God made
man holy, but that man, when he disobeyed the commandment of God, fell into
spiritual death, became dead in the spirit, dead to God, dead in sin, his body
then becoming corruptible and mortal, and he hastening on to death everlasting-,
to the destruction both of body and soul, in the fire never to be quenched. He
declared that the fall of man is the very foundation of revealed religion, and
that it is a, scriptural, practical, rational, experimental doctrine; and from
this utter corruption of man's nature, this death of the soul, he inferred the
necessity of a New Birth, and Justification by faith. He declared that Christian
or saving faith is not an opinion or any number of opinions, be they ever so
true, but is a power wrought by the Almighty in an immortal spirit, inhabiting a
house of clay, to see spiritual and eternal things; that faith is the eye of the
new-born soul, whereby every true believer seeth Him who is invisible; that it
is the ear of the soul, whereby the sinner hears the voice of the Son of God,
and lives; the palate of the soul, whereby a believer tastes the good word and
the powers of the world to come; the feeling of the soul, whereby, through the
power of the Highest overshadowing him, he perceives the presence of Him in whom
he lives, and moves, and has his being, and feels the love of God shed abroad in
his heart. Why have not all men this faith? He asks. Because, he replies, no man
is able to work it in himself; it is a work of omnipotence. It requires no less
power, he says, thus to quicken a dead soul, than to raise a body that lies in
the grave. It is, he adds, a new creation; and none can create a soul anew, but
He who at first created the Heavens and the earth. You know this to be so by
your own experience. Faith is the free gift of God, which He bestows not on
those who are worthy of His favor, not on such as are previously holy, and so
fit to be crowned with all the blessings of His goodness; but on the ungodly and
unholy; on those who, till that hour, were fit only for everlasting destruction;
those in whom was no good thing, and whose only plea was, God, be merciful to
me, a sinner! No merit, no goodness in man, precedes the forgiving love of God.
His pardoning mercy supposes nothing in us but a sense of mere sin and misery;
and to all who see and feel and own their wants, and their utter inability to
remove them, God freely gives faith, for the sake of Him in whom He is always
well pleased. Without faith a man cannot be justified, even though he should
have everything else; with faith he cannot but be, justified, though everything
else should be wanting. This justifying faith implies not only the personal
revelation, the inward evidence of Christianity, but likewise a sure and firm
confidence in the individual believer that Christ died for his sins, loved him,
and gave His life for him. And at what time so ever a sinner thus believes, God
justifieth him. Repentance, indeed, must have been given him before; but that
repentance was neither more nor less than a deep sense of the want of all good,
and the presence of all evil; and whatever good he hath or doth from that hour
when he first believes in God through Christ, faith does not find, but brings.
What clear spiritual light Wesley seemed at times to have on these important
subjects of the new birth, and faith, and repentance; and yet at other times,
when speaking on these same subjects, especially in connection with the doctrine
of predestination and election, with what gross spiritual darkness and
bitterness is his mind filled! In the Conference of 1771 he said: "Take heed to
your doctrine! we have leaned too much toward Calvinism. 1. With regard to man's
faithfulness; our Lord Himself taught us to use the expression, and we ought
never to be ashamed of it. 2. With regard to working for life; this, also, the
Lord has expressly commanded us. Labor, ergazethe, literally, work for the meat
that edureth to everlasting life. 3. We have received it as a maxim, that a man
is to do nothing in order to justification. Nothing can be more false. Whoever
desires to find favor with God should cease from evil, and learn to do well.
Whoever repents, should do works meet for repentance. And if this is not in
order to find favor, what does he do them for? [Just as though the forgiven
penitent had not already found Divine favor, and would not now spontaneously and
gratefully work from a new and living principle of love!] Is not this," he adds,
"salvation by works? Not by the merit of works, but by works as a condition.
What have we then been disputing about for these thirty years? I am afraid,
about words. As to merit itself, of which we have been so dreadfully afraid, we
are rewarded according to our works, yea, because of our works. How does this
differ from for the sake of our works? And how differs this from secundum merita
operum, as our works deserve? Can you split this hair? I doubt I cannot." Thus,
ignoring the most important and essential fact of revelation, that salvation is
entirely of grace, the natural, darkened reason of man reaches the deepest
abysses of Pelagian darkness, and makes salvation entirely of works. The wonder
is how a sane mind can believe two such utterly contradictory systems. Wesley's
bitter opposition to the doctrine of predestination and election is most
conspicuous in his sermon on "Free, Grace," a sermon which he decided by lot
whether to preach and print or not, and a sermon which should have been
entitled, not Free Grace, but Free Will; for, if human language means anything,
it makes the salvation of every sinner depend, not on the free grace of God,
which Wesley represents to be the same to the lost as to the saved, but on the
free will of the sinner, which really carries him to Heaven. The carnal
caricaturing and railing at God's eternal truth (grossly misunderstood and
misrepresented) exhibited in this so-called sermon, instead of being forever
perpetuated in the body of Methodist doctrine, should, as Wesley said of the
name of Methodists, be "buried in eternal oblivion." If God be an eternal and
unchangeable Being, Wesley's own language already quoted in reference to the
spiritual death of all mankind since the fall, and the absolute need of
omnipotent power to create the soul anew, and freely give if repentance and
faith, necessitates the truth of the doctrine of predestination and election;
("The desideratum," says Mr. Alexander Knox, in his eulogistic "Remarks on the
Life and Character of John Wesley"--"The desideratum was a precise distinction
between the supposed irresistibility of Divine grace, maintained by Augustine
and Calvin, and that effective energy, which is so clearly asserted throughout
the New Testament, and so evidently accordant to man's moral exigencies." Now,
who will supply this desideratum, and explain the difference between the
irresistibility and the efficacy of Diving grace? ) insomuch that the acute S.
T. Coleridge "pledges himself to apply every sentence of Wesley's declamation
against election to Wesley's own creed," and Mr. Coleridge declares that "the
only effective way of dealing with the Predestinarians is by demonstrating the
inherent unreality and in consequence of all logic and all logical conclusions
"--but this course would be fatal to all rationalistic religion. Even Mr. Daniel
Curry, of New York, one of the leaders of American Methodism, admits that
Wesley's Treatise on Baptism is a capital instance of blindness; the difficulty
arising from a hopeless attempt to reconcile the Anglican catechism and ritual
to the New Testament. I do not know of any eminent character in ecclesiastical
history more full of doctrinal inconsistences than Mr. John Wesley; and I do not
see how any child of God, with a knowledge of these facts, can substitute John
Wesley's writings (or any other uninspired writings) for the Bible as his
standard of faith and practice.--Charles Wesley (1708-1788), the younger brother
of John, was the poet of Methodism, and the most voluminous of all English
hymnists. Much of his poetry contains false theology, as "O Horrible Decree,"
and "A charge to keep I have;" hut some of his hymns are excellent, as "Jesus,
lover of my soul," "Blow ye the trumpet, "Come, Thou Almighty King," "Blast be
the dear uniting love," and " Come, let us join with saints above."
The Independents, or
Congregationalists, rapidly multiplied in England during the eighteenth century;
and they became the most numerous and influential denomination in America, being
mostly confined to New England. A learned ministry was their pride and boast. In
Connecticut, about 1735, a law was passed providing that no man should be
entitled to recognition as a clergyman who was not a graduate of Yale or Harvard
or of some foreign university. Their ministry had almost unrivaled authority and
influence. President Quincy gives a graphic description of the Congregational
pastor in Andover, Massachusetts, "issuing from his mansion, at the moment of
service, on Sunday morning, with Bible and manuscript sermon under his arm, with
his wife leaning on one arm, flanked by his negro man at his side, as his wife
was by her negro woman, the little negroes being distributed, according to their
sex, by the side of their respective parents; the other members of the family
and visitors then following according to age and rank; the whole congregation
rising and standing till the minister and his family were seated; and at the
close :of the service the whole congregation rising and standing till the
minister and his family had left the meeting-house." The clergy were very
aristocratic, and also showed a marked predilection for political discussions.--
Isaac Watts (1674-1748), an almost life-long invalid, and never married, was an
English Independent minister, and the inventor of English hymns. Besides
versifying the Psalms, he wrote a large number of the best hymns in modern hymn
books, including, "Eternal Power, whose high abode," "Keep silence, all created
things," "Jesus shall reign where'er the sun," "When I survey the wondrous
cross," "Come, we who love the Lord," " Sweet is the work, my God, my King,"
"The Heavens declare Thy glory, Lord," "How beauteous are their feet," "Am I a
soldier of the cross," "Our God, our help in ages past," "How pleasant, how
divinely fair," "Plunged in a gulf of dark despair," "Join all the glorious
names," " My soul, repeat His praise," "Not to ourselves, who are but dust,"
"Let others boast how strong they be," '' How precious is the book Divine," "The
law commands, and makes us know," "Blest is the man, forever bless'd," "Vain are
the hopes the sons of men," "Go, worship at Emmanuel's feet," "Behold the sure
foundation stone," "From all that dwell below the skies," "He dies, the friend
of sinners dies," "Salvation, O the joyful sound," "Come, Holy Spirit, Heavenly
Dove," "Alas, and did my Savior bleed," "Show pity, Lord, O Lord, forgive," "We
are a garden wall'd around," "Lo, what an entertaining sight," "I'm not ashamed
to own my Lord,'' "My God, my Life, my love," "When I can read my title clear,"
"So let our lives and lips express," "Twas on that dark, that doleful night,"
"Jesus is gone above the skies," "How sweet and awful is the place," "Lord, what
is man, poor, feeble man," "Teach me the measure of my days," "There is a land
of pure delight," "There is a house not made with hands," "And must this body
die," and "That awful day will surely come."--Philip Doddridge (1702-1751), an
English Independent minister, was a life-long invalid, a very conscientious man,
and the author of "A Family Expositor" (of the New Testament), "The Rise and
Progress of Religion in the Soul," and of 374 hymns, including, "Grace,'tis a
charming sound," "Do not I love Thee, O my Lord," "Awake, my soul, stretch every
nerve," "O happy day, that fixed my choice," "See Israel's gentle Shepherd
stand," "Jesus, I love Thy charming name," "Jesus, I sing Thy wondrous grace,"
"Savior Divine, we know Thy name," "Dear Savior, we are Thine," "'Tis mine, the
covenant of His grace," " What if death my sleep invade," "Salvation, O
melodious sound," "Ye little flock, whom Jesus feeds," "My God, what silken
cords are Thine," and "While on the verge of life I stand." --Matthew Henry
(1662-1714), an English Non-conformist minister, preached through the whole
Bible, in expository sermons, more than once; and his Exposition of the Bible,
though not scientific or critical, is said to be still the most practical,
devotional and spiritual of all English commentaries. "George Whitefield read it
through four times, the last time on his knees." Matthew Henry's dying language
was: "A life spent in the service of God, and communion with Him, is the most
pleasant life that any one can live in this world."